sciencebriefs
13:00in productionCh. 1 · Vaccines already proven on animals/ 13:00 · ceiling 15 min
Medicine

Rabies vaccine

In July 1885 Louis Pasteur gave an unlicensed, ethically fraught treatment to a bitten nine-year-old, having claimed far more animal testing than his own lab notebooks later showed he had actually done.

Building on his earlier work weakening chicken cholera and anthrax to make vaccines, Louis Pasteur's laboratory, led experimentally by Emile Roux, developed a rabies vaccine by growing the virus in rabbits and progressively weakening it by drying infected nerve tissue. When nine-year-old Joseph Meister was bitten by a rabid dog in July 1885, Pasteur, who held no medical licence, gave him a course of about a dozen injections of increasingly potent vaccine over eleven days; Meister survived, and Pasteur went on to treat 350 people by 1886 with only one later death from rabies. Pasteur had told the world he had successfully vaccinated 50 dogs before risking a human patient, but a later historian's examination of his laboratory notebooks found only 11 dogs had actually been vaccinated, a gap between the public account and the private evidence that has become part of how the case is now read.

Chapters & takeaways6
  1. 0:08
    Vaccines already proven on animals

    Pasteur had already shown that deliberately weakened pathogens could protect chickens against cholera and sheep against anthrax before turning to rabies.

  2. 2:10
    Weakening rabies in rabbit spinal cords

    Pasteur's laboratory grew the rabies virus in rabbits and attenuated it by drying the infected nerve tissue for varying lengths of time.

  3. 4:20
    A bitten boy and an unlicensed doctor

    In July 1885 Pasteur, who was not a physician, directed the treatment of nine-year-old Joseph Meister with a course of increasingly strong vaccine doses.

  4. 6:30
    A claim the notebooks did not support

    Pasteur said he had already vaccinated 50 dogs successfully, but a later historian found his own laboratory records documented only 11.

  5. 8:40
    From one boy to hundreds of patients

    By 1886 Pasteur had treated 350 people bitten by suspected rabid animals, with only one later death, and the treatment spread internationally within a year.

  6. 10:50
    Why the gap in the record matters

    Worth understanding because the treatment worked, but the way its safety was represented to the public did not match what the laboratory notebooks actually recorded.

Worth your time?

Yes. Study the whole thing.

4.5/ 5
What works
  • the concrete progression from chicken cholera to anthrax to rabies as one continuous method being refined
  • the specific, checkable discrepancy between Pasteur's public claim of 50 vaccinated dogs and the 11 his own notebooks recorded
  • the plain outcome numbers, 350 people treated with one later death, without further dressing them up
What does not
  • it does not resolve why Pasteur overstated his animal testing, only that a historian's later review of the notebooks found the gap
  • it does not detail how the ethical standards this case is now measured against developed afterward
Study it if
  • readers who assume famous medical triumphs were also ethically clean
  • anyone interested in how much animal testing actually preceded a famous first human trial
  • readers curious about the practical mechanics of an attenuated vaccine
Skip it if
  • readers wanting a straightforward hero narrative without the notebook discrepancy
  • anyone after the immunology of how attenuated virus vaccines train the immune system
The written brief3 min read

Vaccines already proven on animals

Before turning to rabies, Louis Pasteur had already established that a pathogen deliberately weakened in the laboratory could protect an animal against the full-strength disease. In 1877 he found that chicken cholera bacteria left exposed to air for a long period lost their ability to kill chickens outright while still triggering protection, and in May 1881, at a public demonstration at Pouilly-le-Fort attended by over 200 spectators, sheep and goats given a similarly weakened anthrax preparation survived exposure to the full disease while unvaccinated animals died. These two results established attenuation, weakening a pathogen just enough to provoke immunity without causing the disease itself, as a working method before Pasteur’s laboratory applied the same logic to rabies.

Weakening rabies in rabbit spinal cords

Rabies posed a harder problem, since the causative agent could not yet be grown or observed the way bacteria could. Pasteur’s laboratory, with the rabies work directed experimentally by his assistant Emile Roux, grew the infectious material by passing it through the nervous systems of rabbits and then weakened it by drying the resulting infected spinal cord tissue for varying lengths of time, producing a graded series of preparations ranging from strongly weakened to nearly full strength. The treatment protocol that emerged from this work involved giving a patient a sequence of injections starting with the most weakened material and moving progressively toward stronger preparations over the following days.

A bitten boy and an unlicensed doctor

On 6 July 1885, nine-year-old Joseph Meister, who had been mauled by a rabid dog, became the first person to receive this treatment, given a series of roughly a dozen injections over eleven days under Pasteur’s direction. Pasteur himself held no medical licence, which meant the treatment carried genuine legal and ethical exposure; his colleague Roux, who was a qualified physician, reportedly declined to take part, apparently regarding the human trial as unjust, and two other physicians, Jacques-Joseph Grancher and Alfred Vulpian, were brought in to supervise and administer the injections directly. Meister survived and remained healthy when examined three months later.

A claim the notebooks did not support

Pasteur told the public that he had already successfully vaccinated 50 rabid dogs before risking a human patient, a claim meant to establish that the treatment had been thoroughly proven safe and effective in animals first. A later historian’s examination of Pasteur’s own laboratory notebooks found a considerably smaller number, only 11 dogs actually vaccinated, a substantial gap between the confidence Pasteur projected publicly and what his private records documented. That discrepancy does not appear to have affected the outcome for Meister, but it complicates any account of the episode that treats Pasteur’s own contemporary statements about his preparation as straightforwardly reliable.

From one boy to hundreds of patients

Word of Meister’s recovery spread quickly, and Pasteur went on to treat additional patients, including Jean-Baptiste Jupille later that same year; by 1886 he had treated 350 people bitten by suspected rabid animals, with only one later death from rabies among them, a success rate that drove rapid international adoption of the method, reaching the United States within a year. The demand for treatment centres led to the founding of the Pasteur Institute in Paris in 1887, and within roughly two decades comparable rabies treatment centres, numbering around 75, had opened across multiple countries, including in French Indochina and Siam.

Why the gap in the record matters

This case is worth understanding in full because the treatment’s genuine success does not erase the more uncomfortable details around how it was introduced: an unlicensed practitioner directing human injections, a colleague who reportedly viewed the trial as unjust, and a public claim about prior animal testing that a later, careful check of the actual laboratory notebooks did not fully support. None of this changes the fact that Meister survived and that the treatment went on to save many more lives across the world in the following decades, but reading the achievement alongside the discrepancy gives a far more accurate sense of how this particular piece of medical history actually unfolded.

Same field · Medicine4 of 84
13:00
MMR vaccine and autismIn February 1998, Andrew Wakefield published a paper in The Lancet based on twelve autistic children, proposing a connection between the MMR vaccine and autism through a condition he called autistic enterocolitis, and followed it with a press conference calling for the triple vaccine to be suspended even though the paper itself claimed no causal link had been proven. Investigative journalist Brian Deer subsequently uncovered that Wakefield had undisclosed financial conflicts of interest and had manipulated the patient data underlying the study. The Lancet partially retracted the paper in 2004 and fully retracted it in 2010, the same year Britain's General Medical Council, after a 217-day hearing, struck Wakefield off the medical register for acting dishonestly and irresponsibly. In January 2011, the BMJ, under editor Fiona Godlee, published Deer's full investigation describing the paper as an elaborate fraud. In the meantime, UK MMR vaccination rates fell from 92 percent in 1996 to as low as 61 percent in parts of London, measles cases rose from 56 in 1998 to 449 by mid-2006, and the country saw its first measles death since 1992, with the disease declared endemic again in the UK by 2008 for the first time in fourteen years.
13:00
Smallpox vaccine1798In May 1796 Edward Jenner inoculated eight-year-old James Phipps with pus from a cowpox blister on milkmaid Sarah Nelmes's hand, then deliberately exposed him to smallpox and found he did not fall ill. Jenner published the result along with 23 further cases in 1798, offering a far safer alternative to the existing practice of variolation, deliberate infection with smallpox itself, which killed a real if smaller share of those who underwent it. Vaccination spread across Europe and its colonies within years, was refined over the following two centuries, and underpinned the World Health Organization's campaign that led it to declare smallpox eradicated in 1980, the only human disease eliminated this way to date.
13:00
BCG vaccineBetween 1908 and 1921, Albert Calmette and Camille Guerin at the Pasteur Institute repeatedly subcultured a virulent tuberculosis-related bacterium, 239 times over thirteen years, until it could no longer cause disease in laboratory animals, producing the strain known as Bacille Calmette-Guerin, or BCG. First given to a newborn in Paris in 1921, the vaccine survived a serious setback in 1930 when a contaminated batch in Lubeck, Germany caused tuberculosis in over a hundred infants and killed dozens, a disaster that weighed on Calmette until his death three years later. BCG remains the only licensed tuberculosis vaccine and is used across most of the world, but trials have found its protection ranges from strong and long-lasting in some countries to negligible in others, a variability still not fully explained.
13:00
Combined oral contraceptive pill1961Backed by funding that Margaret Sanger and Katharine McCormick secured for his laboratory, Gregory Pincus worked with Min Chueh Chang to confirm that progesterone could suppress ovulation, then partnered with physician John Rock to test the approach first on infertility patients in Massachusetts and then, at larger scale, on women at birth control clinics in Puerto Rico from 1955. Despite a trial supervisor's report that the drug, sold as Enovid, caused side effects serious enough to be unacceptable, Pincus and Rock pressed ahead, and the Food and Drug Administration approved it for contraceptive use in May 1960. The pill went on to be used by well over 100 million women worldwide, cited widely as a catalyst for broader social change, even as its cardiovascular and cancer risks, weighed against its near-complete effectiveness at preventing pregnancy, remain part of how it is prescribed today.
Up next in Science

Van der Waals equation

Johannes van der Waals · 12:07

It treated molecules as real — before anyone could see them — and made their size and stickiness measurable.

12:07